SBVR Speaks on Rules: Fundamental Principles for Rules

Ronald G.  Ross
Ronald G. Ross Co-Founder & Principal, Business Rule Solutions, LLC , Executive Editor, Business Rules Journal , and Co-Chair, Building Business Capability (BBC) Read Author Bio       || Read All Articles by Ronald G. Ross

What principles in the real world (not software) necessarily underlie meaningful, pragmatic expression of rules and other elements of guidance (i.e., advices and business policies)? SBVR identifies three fundamental principles: Severability, Accommodation, and Wholeness. This extract explains what these principles mean and why they are important. The first principle is a matter of practical necessity. The latter two aim to avoid any and all cases of hidden semantics — no use of priorities or overrides to manipulate evaluation of business rules behind the curtains. Exactly what you express is exactly what you get!

1. The Severability Principle

Principle: The meaning of an element of guidance may be expressed separately from any other element of guidance; nonetheless, a body of shared guidance that includes the element of guidance will be evaluated as if all the elements of guidance had been expressed jointly and all had to hold true.

In everyday business, elements of guidance are individual elements of meaning that exist separately. Often, they are also expressed separately — e.g., by individual sentences. In a body of shared guidance of any size, such separate expression of dissimilar or disjoint elements of guidance is a practical necessity for readability and manageability.

In SBVR, a body of shared guidance is nonetheless logically considered as a whole. In other words, each element of guidance is always applied in all situations where that element of guidance is relevant — even if expressed separately. This is true even if the element of guidance is expressed without direct reference to related elements of guidance that are relevant for the same situation.

This fundamental understanding is called the Severability Principle.[1]

The Merriam-Webster Unabridged Dictionary's definition of "severable" is:

capable of being severed … ; especially : capable of being divided into legally independent rights or obligations used of a statute or contract of which the part to be performed consists of distinct items to which the consideration may be apportioned so that the invalidity or failure of performance as to one item does not necessarily affect the others

This captures the sense of what SBVR means by 'severable'. If one element of guidance is invalidated or violated somehow, the rest still apply.

It should be noted that expressing elements of guidance separately and without reference to related elements of guidance may increase the chance of conflicts, but does not create it per se. Even a single element of guidance can have internal conflicts. Conflicts must be resolved by proper specification, including cases where exceptions are intended.

It should also be noted that the Severability Principle does not apply across separate bodies of shared guidance. Therefore conflicts and exceptions can only exist within a single body of shared guidance. They cannot exist across two or more bodies of shared guidance.

2. The Accommodation Principle

Principle: An element of guidance whose meaning conflicts with some other element(s) of guidance must be taken that way; if no conflict is intended, the element(s) of guidance must be expressed in such a way as to avoid the conflict.

Exceptions to elements of guidance must be accommodated explicitly; that is, cases where exceptions to elements of guidance are intended must be worded in such a way to avoid any conflict in the meanings.

In SBVR, statements can mean only what the actual words presented in the statements indicate they mean. Therefore, to indicate that an exception is intended always requires additional or alternative specification (i.e., accommodation). Otherwise the meanings of the statements would simply (and necessarily) be taken to be in conflict.

Example: Two rules, expressed as individual statements with mutually-exclusive conditions:

1. The state sales tax must be charged on each order shipped within the state.

2. The state sales tax must not be charged on an order shipped out-of-state.

Note that the second rule above would not be considered to be "an exception" to the first. Rather, its expression includes "out-of-state" to differentiate it from orders shipped "within the state". This accommodation avoids a collision between the meanings of the rules that would otherwise arise.

3. The Wholeness Principle

Principle: An element of guidance means only exactly what it says, so it must say everything it means.

Each element of guidance must be self-contained; that is, no need to appeal to any other element(s) of guidance should ever arise in understanding the full meaning of a given element of guidance.

The full impact of an element of guidance for a body of shared guidance, of course, cannot be understood in isolation. For example, an element of guidance might be in conflict with another element of guidance, or act as an authorization in the body of shared guidance. The Wholeness Principle simply means that if a body of shared guidance is deemed free of conflicts, then with respect to guidance, the full meaning of each element of guidance does not require examination of any other element of guidance. In other words, each element of guidance can be taken at face value for whatever it says.


This material is excerpted from the OMG standard Semantics of Business Vocabulary and Business Rules (SBVR), Version 1.5, pp. 102–103 and 107.

References

[1] This SBVR principle is the business counterpart to what in propositional logic is often called the universal 'and'. This assumption requires that all separate propositions be true (for a body of shared guidance). Therefore, an implicit 'and' must be considered to exist between all such propositions.

# # #

Standard citation for this article:


citations icon
Ronald G. Ross , "SBVR Speaks on Rules: Fundamental Principles for Rules" Business Rules Journal Vol. 21, No. 01, (Jan. 2020)
URL: http://www.brcommunity.com/a2020/c019.html

About our Contributor:


Ronald  G. Ross
Ronald G. Ross Co-Founder & Principal, Business Rule Solutions, LLC , Executive Editor, Business Rules Journal , and Co-Chair, Building Business Capability (BBC)

Ronald G. Ross is Principal and Co-Founder of Business Rule Solutions, LLC, where he actively develops and applies the IPSpeak methodology including RuleSpeak®, DecisionSpeak and TableSpeak.

Ron is recognized internationally as the "father of business rules." He is the author of ten professional books including the groundbreaking first book on business rules The Business Rule Book in 1994. His newest are:


Ron serves as Executive Editor of BRCommunity.com and its flagship publication, Business Rules Journal. He is a sought-after speaker at conferences world-wide. More than 50,000 people have heard him speak; many more have attended his seminars and read his books.

Ron has served as Chair of the annual International Business Rules & Decisions Forum conference since 1997., now part of the Building Business Capability (BBC) conference where he serves as Co-Chair. He was a charter member of the Business Rules Group (BRG) in the 1980s, and an editor of its Business Motivation Model (BMM) standard and the Business Rules Manifesto. He is active in OMG standards development, with core involvement in SBVR.

Ron holds a BA from Rice University and an MS in information science from Illinois Institute of Technology. Find Ron's blog on http://www.brsolutions.com/category/blog/. For more information about Ron visit www.RonRoss.info. Tweets: @Ronald_G_Ross

Read All Articles by Ronald G. Ross
Subscribe to the eBRJ Newsletter
In The Spotlight
 Ronald G. Ross
 Jim  Sinur

Online Interactive Training Series

In response to a great many requests, Business Rule Solutions now offers at-a-distance learning options. No travel, no backlogs, no hassles. Same great instructors, but with schedules, content and pricing designed to meet the special needs of busy professionals.